“One of FHA’s New Rules is Postponed”
When HUD initially came out with this new guideline, many of us responded by writing them as to how bad this would be for the public and for the housing recovery. Hard to believe that they responded by postponing the start date, until they re-investigated.
One problem came out of this guideline, not all lenders have postponed the implementation. It isn’t a major issue for us as we deal with many lenders, so when we have a client that has collection accounts over $1,000 we would avoid these lenders.
I wish I knew for sure what HUD will do going forward, but if you have clients that are on the fence, that may have some outstanding collections, help them off. For now we have until July 1st.
FHA postpones rule change for borrowers in debt disputes
Implementation now set for July 1 after additional input and guidance
Jeremy Radack, a real estate attorney who works with Texas builders to obtain mortgages for buyers, recently got a glimpse of what a proposed FHA rule change would mean to his business.
"We saw about a 30 percent to 35 percent decrease in sales," said Radack.
Starting April 1, FHA implemented a new rule that prevented mortgage applicants with $1,000 or more in disputed collections accounts from getting a federally backed loan unless they pay off the debt or can show a multimonth history of paying it down.
On Thursday, April 5, FHA backpedaled on the rule change that it announced in late February. It revised it to exempt unresolved collections that borrowers could show were related to "life events" like medical bills, death, divorce or job loss.
The next day, the agency said it would put off implementing the rule until July 1, to give mortgagees time to absorb the changes. In the meantime, FHA said it intends to seek "additional input on this section and work to clarify guidance, as appropriate." It said the mortgages written while the rule was in effect during the first week in April won't have to comply.
"Most collections issues are due to some life event," said Radack, adding that most people don't take out loans they don't expect to pay back.
Housing analysts have weighed in that the FHA rule changes would have a considerable impact on housing, and builder stocks took a hit last week because of its implications, Wells Fargo Housing analyst Adam Rudiger said in an investment note.
JPMorgan Chase analysts estimated the rule would cut demand for FHA loans by 10 percent to 20 percent in the next few months.
If and when fully implemented, the rule will have a particularly strong impact on young, first-time borrowers and the builders who sell to them, Radack said.
"Your D.R. Hortons, your K.B. Homes, they are all in big, big trouble" if the rule goes into effect, he said.
Radack says that some sort of collection issue is common on first-time buyer applications. "I know first-time homebuyers and I know the starter home market, and that is just the way it is."
Sometimes borrowers got into trouble because they were making very little money and had something happen that caused them to rack up bills that they couldn't pay back.
"My worst fear is that you have someone who has a 750 credit score who, five years ago, when they were in college, broke their leg [didn't have insurance] and had a medical bill they didn't pay because they couldn't," Radack said.
He suspects that most borrowers wouldn't go to the trouble to pay off the collections or to work out a collection plan because it is so difficult to work with creditors once the case has been turned over to collection agencies.
Radack says he understands that FHA is trying to make its loan portfolio stronger but that coming down hard on collections isn't where they should be changing rules.
"Unless there's some secret study that I have never seen, there is absolutely no relation as to how much collections you have and how you pay back your mortgage," he said. Credit scores are a bigger factor in predicting default, he said.
Another good way to strengthen FHA's portfolio, he said, would be to lower the debt-to-income ratio it requires for borrowers, since if a borrower doesn't have any extra money for emergencies, eventually the borrower will default because he or she has no choice.
"Emergencies happen," Radack said.
Joe Petrowsky, NMLS #6869
Right Trac Financial Group, Inc. NMLS #2709
110 Main St.
Manchester, Ct. 06042
Office: 860 647-7701 x116
Fax: 860 647-8940
Cell: 860 836-9294
Joe Petrowsky does not guarantee nor is in any way responsible for the accuracy of the information provided herein, and provides said information without warranties of any kind, either expressed or implied.
Equal Housing Statement: We are pledged to the letter and spirit of U.S. policy for the achievement of equal housing opportunity throughout the Nation. We encourage and support an affirmative advertising and marketing program in which there are no barriers to obtaining housing becuase of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status, or national origin.